Monday, October 14, 2013

Gravity of Criticism

Posted By on Mon, Oct 14, 2013 at 6:00 AM

This weekend I flocked to the theatre to watch Gravity with millions of others. I left the theatre inspired by this work of art and immediately ran home and pulled up my trusty film companion, Rotten Tomatoes. I dug through reviews and listened to Slate and NPR podcasts on the movie. Reading and listening to intelligent discussion of a movie is part of my film-going experience.

As someone engaged in the arts community, I find that most working in the art community approach critical reviews with fear. The perception being that a five star review can make a show, and a one star can break it. In reality, I have never seen a performance, movie or piece of art be universally praised or hated. There are always champions and critics of any work. Sure, in a crowded competitive field a review might help curate ones options, but it's only one of many factors in someone's decision to buy a ticket.

Gravity, for example, is a huge hit with a 98% rating on Tomatometer. Overall critics are saying GO SEE THIS FILM, but at the same time they are opening up a discussion on the movies faults. Rather than blindly praising it, they are also lampooning the hokey dialogue that keeps it from masterpiece status and poking at the plausibility of the realistic looking world it has created. Reading these pieces doesn't stop me from loving Gravity, it just demonstrates that the movie is worthy of discussion. I would say it even amplifies how tremendous the films strengths are that filmgoers can collectively look past these faults.

What true criticism does is help you better understand the piece. That's why I might skim a review before seeing a show, but after I see it is when I really dig in. Good arts criticism writing makes me better articulate what I loved about a piece or what went wrong. And when I don't agree with a critic, it still helps fill out my understanding of the piece.  This is why I seek a variety of opinions. In the world of film reviews, a critic that has studied film can place a piece in context with similar works important to that field, whereas someone reviewing from a pop culture perspective might bring a fresh insight as to why a performance stands out in this moment.

As an arts community we need to better understand the place of criticism in it. Critics need to be encouraged to embrace their role in helping audiences better understand a piece and not fear giving criticism good or bad.  Most the time in Indianapolis I can't have my Gravity experience and dig through a variety of viewpoints of a local performance. I am lucky if I get even one. This past month, Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike at the Phoenix Theatre drove almost every critic in town to review the show. There was an understanding that this performance was a central touch point in our Indianapolis theater season. Some reviewers loved it, some didn't. In my review I praised it, but still found fault with it. Regardless, it was refreshing to see a variety of viewpoints on one show.

Despite the decline in print reviews or official news media coverage, a savvy Indianapolis arts consumer can now seek out more arts criticism than ever with talented bloggers filling in the gaps.

In my opinion, these are some Indianapolis reviewers to follow:

Tom Alvarez

Hope Baugh

Allison Carter

Melissa Hall

Lou Harry

Jay Harvey

NUVO (Various reviewers)

Mission Intrigue (Various reviewers)

  • Pin It
  • Favorite
  • Email

Tags: , , ,

Speaking of...

  • Freeze Frames

    Twitter account @OnePerfectShot captures stunning moments in moving pictures.
    • May 15, 2014
  • Movie Review: Her

    It’s not about falling in love with Siri, according to reviewer Ed Johnson-Ott.
    • Jan 12, 2014
  • Review: Les Mis

    Rita Kohn gives Beef and Boards production of Les Miserables 5 stars only because that's as high as the scales go.
    • Oct 13, 2013
  • More »


Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

Readers also liked…

  • Well-Endowed Artists

    Jennifer draws Seinfeld-esque parallels to artists' financial challenges with education, but offers easy ways to help.
    • Mar 2, 2016
  • Positive Impressions

    Ben chats with IMA’s artist-in-residence about introducing the process of woodblock printmaking to the masses.
    • Jan 10, 2016

About The Author

Justin Brady

Justin Brady

Justin Brady is a nonprofit marketing and fundraising consultant with a passion for the arts. Justin got his start in Indy working with IndyFringe and now seeks out local theatre, film, and dance at every opportunity. He geeks out listening to pop culture podcasts and has an endless Netflix queue.

More by Justin Brady

  • Costume Inspirations

    Justin offers up Halloween costume suggestions inspired by local theatrical productions' wardrobes.
    • Oct 27, 2014
  • Offbeat & Odd

    To seek theater with a side of adventure, Justin recommends veering off the beaten path to find these quirky, one-of-a-kind performances.
    • Oct 13, 2014
  • Theater at the Movies

    Justin provides a rich lineup of NYC and London theatrical productions we'll be able to catch at several of the local cineplexes this fall.
    • Sep 29, 2014
  • More »

Latest in Sky Blue Blog

  • The Nice Things

    Ben has enjoyed his opportunity to give notice to some of Indy’s 'nice things' with Sky Blue Window readers. He hopes you’ll find and share them too.
    • Mar 9, 2016
  • A Gray Sky-onara

    Dan looks back at some of his most memorable blogs at Sky Blue Window.
    • Mar 8, 2016
  • Well-Endowed Artists

    Jennifer draws Seinfeld-esque parallels to artists' financial challenges with education, but offers easy ways to help.
    • Mar 2, 2016
  • More »
© 2017 CICF
Privacy Policy
Contact Us:
P: 317.634.2423   F: 317.684.0943
Central Indiana Community Foundation
615 N. Alabama St. #119
Indianapolis, Indiana 46204-1431
Sky Blue Window is presented by:

Website powered by Foundation